User:Hyperbole/VFG

Welcome to the informal beta page of Vote For Good Articles.

I'm trying to create a list of articles that are, in the opinion of the masses, "kewl".

I'm hoping that this evolves into something more formal, but for now, it's totally informal. Here are the rules.

1. Self-noms are fine and encouraged.
2. Any page whose score goes to +5 gets added to the list of good articles. If you see a page with a +5 score, please feel free to add it to this list and archive its entry.
3. Any page that gets 7 "Good" votes, regardless of the number of "Not Good" votes, gets added to that page.
4. Nominations of quasi-featured or featured articles are invalid.
5. Any page that goes to -2 fails.
6. Any page that does not get enough votes within one month fails.
7. Feel free to continue voting on an article until it is archived. These votes won't change the verdict after-the-fact, only the score.
8. For now, please don't add any templates or categories or otherwise fuck with the article in question.
9. If an article fails VFG due to a low score, please don't re-nom it unless it changes significantly. If an article fails due to a timeout, feel free to re-nom it after a month.
10. Please feel free to smith any entry that's either failed or been promoted, by moving the entry to this page. Try to smith only once a day or two and remove all promoted and failed articles when smithing.

Last smithed: --Scofield 07:05, February 23, 2011 (UTC)

The archives: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5

Rickroll

Score: +1
Good	Good Decided to give this article a read. It's frigging hilarious! --Scofield 15:59, April 28, 2011 (UTC)
Not Good
Comments

Bad Nigga Attitude

Score: +2
Good	Good Funnybony's hilarious piece isn't Uncy's prime time cup of tea, but here in the backwaters, it's uber-good. Nice work. Aleister 10:59 26-3-'11 I'll not normally venture over here, but Aleister's got a point. 1234 ~ 11:04, 26 March 2011 Yaosir!!!--Funnybony    21:13, Mar 30
Not Good	Against Funnybony is one of my favourite writers, but I just don't like this one. mAttlobster. (hello) 16:17, April 28, 2011 (UTC)
Comments

Talk:Garfield

Score: +1
Good	Good Hilarious, especially the "Notice" section. --Scofield 15:07, March 14, 2011 (UTC)
Not Good
Comments

Final Fantasy I

Score: +4
Good	Good This one failed badly at VFH. However, I love it, and I'm pretty sure this is the best of all Final Fantasy articles. A stamp of approval would be appreciated. --Scofield 10:51, February 6, 2011 (UTC)  For. per above. --Mn-z 02:45, March 4, 2011 (UTC)  For. " " .--Funnybony    11:33, Mar 29 GOOD Good and scary. Aleister 12:25 4-6-'11
Not Good
Comments

User:Mnbvcxz/Preggobear

Score: +2
Good	Good this is pregnancy-related article I made almost a year ago that I want to get some feedback on. And since pee review is backlogged, I decided to take it here. --Mn-z 16:49, October 8, 2010 (UTC)  Gooth I read this again yesterday while looking for pictures, and it's really good. It grew on me, like a fungus, and since I couldn't wash it off I say Very good. Aleister 00:44 4-3-'11 And what sort of pictures where you looking for? --Mn-z 01:09, March 4, 2011 (UTC) The preggo ones, finally found that one to use on the Trig Palin page, might have been two days ago. Preggo! Aleister 1:12 4-3-'11 Prevert. --Mn-z 01:23, March 4, 2011 (UTC)
Not Good
Comments

User:Meganew/UnScripts:A Girl and Her Newt

Score: +3
Good	Good funny in a creepy/I can't believe he went there way. --Mn-z 03:16, August 15, 2010 (UTC)  I dig that. Finally! Someone else thought it was good! --High Gen. Meganew (Stuff I've Done) (Chat With Me) (Get an Award!) FORCES ENLIST MUN 22:17, September 8, 2010 (UTC)  Why?:Didn't I vote for this before? Perfect for VFG! Aleister 19:15 18-3-'11
Not Good
Comments	Oh... my... fucking... God. pillow talk 22:22, September 8, 2010 (UTC) Is that a good or bad thing? --High Gen. Meganew (Stuff I've Done) (Chat With Me) (Get an Award!) FORCES ENLIST MUN 22:43, September 8, 2010 (UTC) What Meganew said, we need more feedback. --Mn-z 16:50, October 8, 2010 (UTC) What... 1234 ~ 01:40, 4 March 2011 Again, is that a good or a bad "what..." ? --Mn-z 02:49, March 4, 2011 (UTC)

UnTunes:Troops on the Ground

Score: +1
Good	Self Good A mix of a newer iconic tune with recent-historical iconic morons. Aleister 20:21 23 6 MMX
Not Good
Comments

Foreplay

Score: +3
Good	Nom & Self-for Originally a stub written by Kakun, I expanded on it a lot and added pictures. Hope ya'll niggas enjoy it. —Pelozurian (talk) 08:45, 8 June 2010 (UTC)  Made me cum. Twice. Twice. If only once, I would have voted "Not Good". Aleister 16:59 12 6 MMX Cool. I like, although would prefer more lols. Nominally Humane! some time Sunday, 02:59, Jun 13 2010 UTC
Not Good
Comments

HowTo:Become the king of pop

Score: +3
Good	I liked it, and that's the important thing. Right? Nominally Humane! some time Tuesday, 02:34, Jun 1 2010 UTC  Gooth When I first saw this I followed the instructions, started to use it, and I've been laid every day since. It works! Al des chains 2:43 1 6 MMX Feature.~ 04:46, Jun 9, 2010
Not Good
Comments

Shetland Islands

Score: +1
Good	Good This was nominated for VFD in 2008 and rewritten quite excellently by some of our resident Brittanians. —Pelozurian (talk) 01:29, 17 May 2010 (UTC)
Not Good
Comments

School of Rock

Score: +2
Good	Good Why not? Would you like a cookie, sir? 00:11,15May,2010  Rockin' For the good writing, but more  For. the MP-3 version. Modus. Al sans chains 00:21 15 5 MMX
Not Good
Comments

Find the Froggy

Score: +2
Good	Self-nom and  Yay! Haven't ever shown this off. Needs an airing and a good home. Aleister sans Chains 17:46 10 5 MMX  Aye. Probably not feature worthy, but I think its good, nonetheless. --Matfen 22:26, May 10, 2010 (UTC)
Not Good
Comments	I'll abstain for now to see if there's something I'm missing about this... pillow talk 21:55, May 10, 2010 (UTC) What? Would you like a cookie, sir? 00:25,15May,2010

Don't Eat The Yellow Snow

Score: +2
Good	Self-nom and  Good Wrote this and decided to see what other people thought of it. Constructive criticism appreciated, shots to the balls are not.--Sirrah CatshirE Chess the Striker2117 02:05, May 4, 2010 (UTC)  Good!!! Very well done. And I learned something, don't eat the yellow snow. I've been doing it ass-backwards all along! Aleister unchained 21:16 4 5 MMX
Not Good
Comments

Buddhism

Score: +3 sacred monks
Good	Good People seemed to be afraid to vote in this one while it was on VFH. Would you like a cookie, sir? 00:48,23March,2010 Good I have meditated for hours, and have finally overcome my fear of voting for this page. Before my fear comes back, Good Bodhi Bob 00:53 23 3 mmx OM Shantih Shantih Shantih. Reads a bit messy, but for the most part it's fine.--Sirrah CatshirE Chess the Striker2117 04:17, May 5, 2010 (UTC) Good. —Sir Socky (talk) (stalk) GUN SotM UotM PMotM UotY PotM WotM 14:03, 13 May 2010
Not Good	Not good there is just something off about this, it doesn't seem to work, and I can't really put my finger on it. --Mn-z 00:33, March 28, 2010 (UTC)
Comments