User:EMC/PLS/Results2

PLS Judging

This is where you, the judges, put your results for the PLS. Please list your top 5 articles, in order, best article starting at 1. Remember, the deadline for results is August 12th. If you cannot complete judging before this deadline, please let me know on my talk page or on the talk page of this page.

Scoring system based on judges' top fives will go as follows:
5 points for #1
4 points for #2
3 points for #3,
And so on.

Best Article

• Judge #1: 15Mickey20

1. User:Cap'n Ben/The Gathering Horror

2. User:Mrthejazz/Getting pushed into bananas (Mario Kart)

3. User:The Thinker/Interpretive Death

4. User:Knucmo2/Pulitzer_Prize

5. User:Zombiebaron/wip/Epic_poetry

Honourable mention to User:Bradaphraser/Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which came so close to pipping ZB to fifth.

• Judge #2: An Ape that Only Exists on Thursdays

1. User:Gerrycheevers/Gemini

2. User:Mrthejazz/Getting pushed into bananas (Mario Kart)

3. User:Cap'n Ben/The Gathering Horror

4. User:The Thinker/Interpretive Death

5. User:Knucmo2/Pulitzer Prize

For detailed feedback (or feedforward, if that's what you're in to) on every article see here.

• Judge #3: Squiggle

1. User:Cap'n Ben/The Gathering Horror

2. User:The Thinker/Interpretive Death

3. User:RAHB/Observational Comedy

4. User:Mrthejazz/Getting pushed into bananas (Mario Kart)

5. User:TheLedBalloon/Physics Act of 1707

Honourable mention to User:Bradaphraser/Universal Declaration of Human Rights, User:Knucmo2/Pulitzer_Prize, User:Sycamore/The Philosophy of Massive Attack, and User:Zombiebaron/wip/Epic poetry. All of these guys at some point occupied a spot on my top five. Now is the time to take your bow.

Best Noob Article

• Judge #1: The UnIdiot

1. User:Hyperbole/Pontius Pilates

2. User:ShuaDaddy/Sweatshop (humanitarian institution)

3. User:Cheapinitreal/Tom O'Dell

4. User:Antarktisandtrade;/Adjustable gastric band AKA lap band

5. User:Kingorderve/Prerecorded_Friends

• Judge #2: gwax

1. User:ShuaDaddy/Sweatshop (humanitarian institution)

2. User:Hyperbole/Pontius Pilates

3. User:Cheapinitreal/Tom O'Dell

4. User:Kingorderve/Prerecorded_Friends

5. User:Antarktisandtrade;/Adjustable gastric band AKA lap band

• Judge #3: Mightydandylion

1. User:ShuaDaddy/Sweatshop (humanitarian institution)

2. User:Hyperbole/Pontius Pilates

3. User:Cheapinitreal/Tom O'Dell

4. User:Antarktisandtrade;/Adjustable gastric band AKA lap band

5. User:Kingorderve/Prerecorded_Friends

Best Alt. Namespace Article

• Judge #1: YesTimeToEdit

1. User:Modusoperandi/UnTunes:White trash girl

2. User:Mhaille/How To:Survive a Japanese Game Show

3. User:Cajek/Polar Express

4. User:Zombiebaron/wip/UnPoetia:T.S. Elliot Is Dead

5. User:Orian57/UnBooks: Lyle Crump's Guide to starting secondary school

• Judge #2: MrN9000

1. User:Modusoperandi/UnTunes:White trash girl

2. User:Cajek/Polar Express

3. User:Mhaille/How To:Survive a Japanese Game Show

4. User:Orian57/UnBooks: Lyle Crump's Guide to starting secondary school

5. User:ShuaDaddy/HowTo:Be a surfer

Feedback can be found here...

• Judge #3: Cap'n Ben

1. User:Mhaille/How To:Survive a Japanese Game Show

2. User:Modusoperandi/UnTunes:White trash girl

3. User:Cajek/Polar Express

4. User:ShuaDaddy/HowTo:Be a surfer

5. User:Zombiebaron/wip/UnPoetia:T.S. Elliot Is Dead

Best Illustrated

• Judge #1: Under user

1. The Incredible Adventures of MS PAINTMAN!

2. 11-Wide

3. Sausage party

4. UnBooks:Where's the White House?

5. -

Justification here.

• Judge #2: Kip the Dip

1. The Incredible Adventures of MS PAINTMAN!

2. Sausage party

3. 11-Wide

4. UnBooks:Where's the White House? (Would have come in much higher, but it needs more work.)

5. RoxNews

• Judge #3: ENeGMA

1. User:The_UnIdiot/MSPAINTMAN

2. User:RAHB/11-Wide

3. User:Zombiebaron/wip/Sausage_party

4.

5. User:Gert5/UnBooks:Where's the White House?.

Best Rewrite

• Judge #1: Syndrome

1. User:Hyperbole/Rock lobster

2. User:Under user/HowTo:Be A Supervillain

3. User:15Mickey20/Sania Mirza

4. User:Heerenveen/Driving in Bucharest

5. User:Hindleyite/Mini

What DJ Irreverent said. Good run, guys. I'll try to give some brief feedback over the next week or so.

• Judge #2: DJ Irreverent

1. User:15Mickey20/Sania Mirza

2. User:Heerenveen/Driving in Bucharest

3. User:Under user/HowTo:Be A Supervillain

4. User:Hindleyite/Mini

5. User:Sycamore/BBC

HM to the rest of the articles, they were all very good and it was difficult to choose a winner.

• Judge #3: Thekillerfroggy

1. User:15Mickey20/Sania_Mirza

2. User:Under user/HowTo:Be A Supervillain

3. User:Heerenveen/Driving in Bucharest

4. User:Sonic80/Heath Ledger

5. User:Hindleyite/Mini

Best Judge

• Judge #1: Zombiebaron

1. <span title="Brian Smith, Grand Inquisitor" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Brian Smith, Grand Inquisitor

2. <span title="Grover Cleveland, Mayor of Detroit" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Grover Cleveland, Mayor of Detroit

3. <span title="My dog, Mr. Fluffers" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">My dog, Mr. Fluffers

4. <span title="Franklin U. Gunderthunder, Esquire" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Franklin U. Gunderthunder, Esquire

5. <span title="Sir Thomas P. Redflounder, Grand Duchess of Chile" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Sir Thomas P. Redflounder, Grand Duchess of Chile

• Judge #2: Zombiebaron

1. <span title="Duke" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Duke

2. <span title="Duke" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Duke

3. <span title="Duke" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Duke

4. <span title="Duke of Earl" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Duke of Earl

5. <span title="My dog, Mr. Fluffers" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">My dog, Mr. Fluffers

• Judge #3: Zombiebaron

1. <span title="My dog, Mr. Fluffers" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">My dog, Mr. Fluffers

2. <span title="Alex Trebek" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Alex Trebek

3. <span title="James Dean" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">James Dean

4. <span title="Elvis" class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">Elvis

5. <span title="That guy who looks like Ted Danson, but isn't Ted Danson." class="fakelinks" style="cursor: pointer">That guy who looks like Ted Danson, but isn't Ted Danson.