| Article: CSI: Swansea
|
Score: -3 detectives. That's DCI Hunt to you, mush
|
| Nominated by:
|
Picton 17:16, 18 December 2008 (UTC)
|
For: 0
|
No for votes
|
Against: 3
|
- Against. And not for fear of further alienating those who don't understand Welshiness. Parts are very funny, but there are a lot of lists, red links, and some prose problems. I would try amending this, but I fear you would send me a copy of the page covered in your own excrement. IronLung 04:32, 19 December 2008 (UTC)
- Weak Against. Not bad, but not featurable. RabbiTechno 09:54, 20 December 2008 (UTC)
- Against. For every decent bit, there is a not decent bit. It was way better than I expected, but not a feature by some distance. If there were some ruthless pruning done, and a bit more good stuff added, it could well do better on a second try. --UU - natter
 11:13, Dec 20
|
| Comments
|
- Hm... I'm gonna go ahead and abstain. The article is quite, quite good, with some awesome content in parts and strays from random hysteria. However, whilst any city could have a CSI: Thisplace article made about them, there is also the slight risk that some users won't understand the Welsh jokes (but I may well be very wrong) and also the worrying population of red links everywhere, but I do admit these are but little niggles. But, it's a weak for and a weak against in either case. I like this article, but this doesn't necessicate a vote from me, I'm afraid. Get it pseudo-nom'd, although, with some development, I might vote for this article. --Nachlader 19:09, 18 December 2008 (UTC)
 Abstain.. What Nachlader said. • • • Necropaxx (T) {~} 22:44, Dec 19
|
VFH
← Back to summary VFH
← Back to full VFH
Abstain.. What Nachlader said. 