UnBooks talk:My New Life as a T-Rex
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Uh, I don't think we've met, Mr. Hilarious. :D • <3:05, 31 May 2008>
- GODDAMMIT WAIT UNTIL ITS FINISHED! And thanks, maybe you'll review it when it's done? ~Minitrue Sir SysRq! Talk! Sex! =/ GUN • WotM • RotM • AotM • VFH • SK • PEEING • HP • BFF @ 13:01 May 31
I may be T-Rex, but I not a gay T-Rex. Beautiful. -OptyC Sucks! CUN17:04, 31 May
Go T. rex! -Sockpuppet of an unregistered user 00:26, 8 February 2009 (UTC)
Holy cow; I've been away from Uncyc for a LONG time and this is the funniest thing I've seen since I started checking back every now and then. --The Acceptable Cainad (Fnord) 16:18, 8 February 2009 (UTC)
My word, this is brilliant. --Nikau 10:37, 20 June 2009 (UTC)
Jeez. This is great. Really. Sir Ptok-BentonicznyPisz tutaj • KUN 12:43, November 1, 2009 (UTC)
Review #1 by Optimuschris[edit source]
Humour: | 7 | I hate this part, so let's get it over with first. It's funny, no doubt. I think it's ready for mainspace right now. The mental image of a sad-sack T-Rex kills me. I think the title's fine as well; I can't think of anthing better anyway. When the narrator ate the girl he was flirting with I genuinely LOL'ed but...that was the only time. The rest of the article only managed to illicit grins and nods. The tone is right and I enjoyed the read but it just didn't make me laugh like some other things I've read. So, to recap. Funny. Not that funny. I LOVE YOU MAN! |
Concept: | 9 | I love the concept. It kinda seems like Uncyc's version of "The Metamorphosis". It's weird and original and full of dinosaur. Neato. Ummm. I guess I really got nothing else to add here so I think I'll fill out the section with random discussion of the weather. It's cloudy and chilly here and THIS IS A VERY GOOD CONCEPT. |
Prose and formatting: | 9 | Another nine! You must have done this before because besides a couple minor spelling mistakes (that I'll be damned if I'm gonna go back and find again to fix) I saw nothing that should be corrected. The prose is also spot on. If anything, I'd say maybe find a way to make the main character seem even more pathetic, but it's great how it is. |
Images: | 7 | The pictures are fine, nothing really exciting but perfectly suitable. The caption on the last one gave me a chuckle. I'd give you some suggestions for better images but finding good images is really hard for me and I got nothing. A high heel caught in the teeth of the T-Rex maybe? I dunno. |
Miscellaneous: | 8 | Averaged, but you're an above average dude! Did I mention I love you? It's a good article, but is it VFH worthy? Tough call. I'd vote for it if that means anything, but I have a feeling it might fall a little short. Mainspace it and I'll run it up the flagpole for you. |
Final Score: | 40 | Hey look, 40! That's not too shabby kid! |
Reviewer: | OptyC Sucks! CUN13:34, 2 Jun |
Review #2, by Cajek[edit source]
Humour: | 8.8 | no, you didn't edit conflict me, neener neener
|
Concept: | 9 | This is a great article. One of the most imaginative I have ever read. |
Prose and formatting: | 9 | Good prose, excellent. |
Images: | 8 | The only one I didn't get was the band one. Maybe I'm missing something? I never give high scores on images, but you did better than okay. |
Miscellaneous: | 8.7 | avg |
Final Score: | 43.5 | I'm gonna nom this. |
Reviewer: | • <16:08, 02 Jun 2008> |