Uncyclopedia:Pee Review/I Respectfully Disagree

From Uncyclopedia, the content-free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

I Respectfully Disagree[edit source]

Humour: 5 It's OK, some parts are even outright brilliant like the "fuck off and die" at the end, but too derivative (see "concept" notes).
Concept: 0 This article seems to be too derivative of Uncyclopedia is the worst, so I can't really give too many points for originality.
Prose and formatting: 10 Obviously you spent a considerable amount of time writing this (don't correct me if you didn't). I like how it combines mock-sophistication with the simple blunt effectiveness of fuck you. The concept may not be the most original, but the writing style is a work of sheer brilliance, and I think that alone redeems the article of any other minor sins.
Images: 10 There were none – the perfect article!
Miscellaneous: 10 Partially because of how you respectfully entreat us to please go fuck ourselves. And I actually can kind of understand the perspective of "Mr. Chomsky" (maybe his ideas were sleeping too furiously?), since I've actually said some brilliant stuff before that was lost because I was just a little bit ticked at the jackass who had the nerve to so rudely ignore me.
Final Score: 35 Maybe it kind of plays too much on existing jokes, but the hell with it, “Conversely, Encyclopaedia Dramatica is more akin to the popular children in school and consequently is more likely to amuse. Crap crap crap carp carp!” has to be one of the greatest lines ever posted on this site. If you tried for VFH I'd nominate it and not think twice.
Reviewer: Ninjastar-no.png Megalomaniac Martin “The Unfortunately Unfeatured” Ultima(VOTE FOR ME!)talk(AND MY PICS TOO!)contribs 21:30, 5 July 2007 (UTC)