Talk:Canadians: Difference between revisions
imported>Braydie (From Pee Review) |
No edit summary |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
+ | {{talkheader}} |
||
+ | |||
This page was originally planned as a rewrite of [[Canadians]], but when it was done I thought it was off-topic enough that it ended up as [[Canada/Origin]]. Later I decided that my initial instinct was correct, so it's here now (the original [[Canadians]] text was VFD'd, as it was abysmal). [[User:Modusoperandi|Modusoperandi]] 05:22, 15 August 2006 (UTC) |
This page was originally planned as a rewrite of [[Canadians]], but when it was done I thought it was off-topic enough that it ended up as [[Canada/Origin]]. Later I decided that my initial instinct was correct, so it's here now (the original [[Canadians]] text was VFD'd, as it was abysmal). [[User:Modusoperandi|Modusoperandi]] 05:22, 15 August 2006 (UTC) |
||
Revision as of 23:51, 29 June 2007
This is the talk page for discussing improvements to Canadians.
| ||
---|---|---|
|
Article policies
|
This page was originally planned as a rewrite of Canadians, but when it was done I thought it was off-topic enough that it ended up as Canada/Origin. Later I decided that my initial instinct was correct, so it's here now (the original Canadians text was VFD'd, as it was abysmal). Modusoperandi 05:22, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
From Pee Review
Every year, around Canada Day (Fête du Canada too. Both conveniently fall on July 1th, which is nice), I get all nationalistic and nom a Canadaish page on VFH. Last year, Canada, which I nom'd on July 3nd, because I'm both forgetful and my memory doesn't work so good. This year, Canadians, unless I forget again. Yes, it's mine, but it turned out nice, and I walk it and comb its fur every day. I do! Well, enough rambling. It's got history, less the names and places and dates. Hopefully it's Canadian without being too Canadian. Hoser for hosers of all nations, in other words. Opinions? --Sir Modusoperandi Boinc! 10:08, 6 April 2007 (UTC)
Humour: | 6 | A couple of giggles, not hilarious, but funny enough to be worthwhile. |
Concept: | 6 | Not much to say here. You pretty much wrote in a humorous way about Canadians |
Prose and formatting: | 8 | Very readable |
Images: | 6 | I like the map one, the others are OK. |
Miscellaneous: | 6.8 | million trees to every man. |
Final Score: | 32.8 | It's quite a nice article, slightly informative but that's not necessarily a bad thing. I'm amazed you haven't mentioned ice hockey, as that's the first thing most people think of when someone mentions Canadians. |
Reviewer: | --Kelpan 21:28, 7 April 2007 (UTC) |
Sorry I couldn't think of more useful comments, but would you like a user template?
…and unabashedly proud of it.
(But they're not saying where they're from in case y'all come and bomb the hell out of it.)
(List of NonAmerican Uncyclopedians)
- Slightly informative is what I was aiming for. Too informative would potentially fill it with dates and names (my favourite "bit" is still reducing the Plains of Abraham, a major turning point in Canadian history, to a single line). I didn't mention hockey because I, um, don't like hockey. /me hides under desk. And thanks for the template; I won't use it, as I try not to define myself by what I'm not, but thanks anyway (and I already have the Canadian template hidden away somewhere under my userpage). --Sir Modusoperandi Boinc! 16:12, 8 April 2007 (UTC)