User:Prettiestpretty/Aristocrat's Turkey Day Ball/Voting
User:Darwin of suburbia/Maddie McCann
| Overall Humo(u)r: |
1/10 Humor was tepid. Where was the "ick" factor? | |
| Delivery: |
1/10 Delivery was weak as well, again, where was the ick factor? | |
| Miscellaneous/Bonus: |
1/10 Get a point for entering. Yeah, I'm a hard ass bitch, too. | |
| Final Score: |
3/30 | |
| Judge: |
Dame | |
| Overall Humo(u)r: |
3/10 It was there, but not fully flushed out | |
| Delivery: |
2/10 The layout got me as sparse - there was all that white space at top and lots of white space feels unfinished. | |
| Miscellaneous/Bonus: |
10/10 Nice play on words, good use of image and it had a great beat to dance to. | |
| Final Score: |
15/30 | |
| Judge: |
Dame | |
User:Jedravent/HowTo:Eat Food Provocatively
| Overall Humo(u)r: |
2/10 I was waiting for the text to be more provactive. | |
| Delivery: |
2/10 Have you seen this film called When Harry Met Sally? | |
| Miscellaneous/Bonus: |
10/10 All for effort, it should be rewarded | |
| Final Score: |
14/30 | |
| Judge: |
Dame | |
User:The_UnIdiot/Why?:Use a wooden condom
| Overall Humo(u)r: |
6/10 Humor was all about, but I was looking for the raunch and just got a splinter of it. | |
| Delivery: |
6/10 Delivery was good. | |
| Miscellaneous/Bonus: |
6/10 Good layout - it left me feeling full. | |
| Final Score: |
18/30 | |
| Judge: |
Dame | |
| Overall Humo(u)r: |
8/10 - I was like "what the heck" until I got to the Rape of Nanking and then it was like "all right!" | |
| Delivery: |
10/10 - It built up to the right place and then delivered, and again, and again. | |
| Miscellaneous/Bonus: |
10/10 | |
| Final Score: |
28/30 My top pick. | |
| Judge: |
Dame | |
User:Gerrycheevers/UnNews:Saudi woman flogged for being gang raped
| Overall Humo(u)r: |
1/10 I knew what you were going for, but it took too long to get there. | |
| Delivery: |
4/10 It eventually dropped its payload | |
| Miscellaneous/Bonus: |
5/10 There was a lot of effort put into this | |
| Final Score: |
10/30 Too much like a straight news story for me | |
| Judge: |
Dame | |
User:GopherKiller/UnNews:Six Flags to sell severed legs in gift shop
| Overall Humo(u)r: |
2/10 Found the humor | |
| Delivery: |
2/10 Found where the punchline was delivered | |
| Miscellaneous/Bonus: |
10/10 Gets A+ for formatting and original image | |
| Final Score: |
14/30 | |
| Judge: |
Dame | |
User:Zombiebaron/UnPoetia:I Don't Like People Who Aren't Like Me
| Overall Humo(u)r: |
4/10 Its there | |
| Delivery: |
4/10 Its delivered at the door with a quick din dong | |
| Miscellaneous/Bonus: |
10/10 It made me weep. | |
| Final Score: |
14/30 But I didn't cry hard enough. | |
| Judge: |
Dame | |