Uncyclopedia talk:Pee Review/Jewish Cuisine

I think that Chiefjustice exaggerated some issues. E.g. I really liked those transitions to infromal random humor which Chiefjustice pointed out as inappropriate. ;p I believe he is just oversensitive. Be cool and only you need to do is adding "signs" to the dishes that miss "signs" in your article. Sir Ptok-Bentoniczny^{Pisz tutaj} • KUN 20:14, February 9, 2010 (UTC)

Look, I am fine with you offering criticism of your own and making them with regard to my comments. However what is not acceptable is leaving them on the talk page of the review and arguing against what I said in the review, if you disagree with something I said make the author of the article aware on their talk page, and be constructive when you do it, saying something like "I think what Chief said is true for some people, but I think that etc etc." is absolutely fine and I welcome that sort of criticism of my work; it helps me improve and the author gains a new perspective. You do not simply say "Chief is wrong, do this and everything will be OK".

I hope I am making myself clear. --ChiefjusticeDS 21:47, February 9, 2010 (UTC)

Don't take it personally, I just've left here my opinion on the article compared to yours. That's all. Now they have two cows opinions and they should be more happy. Doesn't it work like this? Sir Ptok-Bentoniczny^{Pisz tutaj} • KUN 22:50, February 9, 2010 (UTC)