Talk:Silent film

movie vs film

I think this article deserves the dignity of being voted on for a major rewrite. I wrote "silent Film" it got rewritten in a complete make-over which changed the nature of the joke. It is not unrealistic to have multiple versions of a topic. If my redirect replacement revert is deemed unwarranted, please bring it to a vote at VFD. I simply stand by the premise of this article, but also like the Silent movie as well. Can't we have both? Kevillips (TMS) MUN,CM,NS 03:53, 13 February 2013 (UTC)

PS, I think most people will agree to a distinction to say all movies are not films

Kevillips (TMS) MUN,CM,NS 03:53, 13 February 2013 (UTC)

Requested article

"Silent Film" was a requested article. Over time, it seemed to have been forwarded to "Silent movie" then blanked by a new writer. What I have done is restore this to its proper title, and left Silent Movie as is, kept them both in unfilm, and put a whoops on this one to the other one, in case some people did not know of the redirect. I wonder if I put too much thought into this? At least, I can sleep. Kevillips (TMS) MUN,CM,NS 21:24, 14 February 2013 (UTC)