UnDebate:Are Tropical Storm Amanda and Cristobal the same storm

From Uncyclopedia, the content-free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search


Background information[edit]

The TCR made it sort of clear Amanda formed from Cristobal, and LightandDark2000 merged them. This has recieved contreversy on Wikipedia for borderline original research, and other things. With proposals to move, or more likely split, with people saying LDK2000 was only doing it cause he wanted to.

Argument[edit]

Are Tropical Storm Amanda and Cristobal the same storm?

Yes[edit]

Of course! The circulation remained intact. Cristobal lost 9 deaths which were double counted with Amanda the bitch. It's like Beryl 2018, except crossed basins. It's like Tropical Depression 11E and Tropical Storm Hermine of 2010.

No[edit]

Fuck to the fuckidity no! 11E and Hermine make the death untangling more confusing, even if that wasn't true, it was direct, this had other factors. Moving it to a flood article is a bad idea, but damn! This was indirect, causing an original research track map, as they have a stop for a day. Maybe you should read, "After landfall, Amanda moved northward across Guatemala, and its center dissipated before 1800 UTC 31 May over the mountainous terrain of the country." Backed up here. Wow are you dumb. Didn't even read the TCR fully?

Argument[edit]

Ok, but should they at least be in the same article?

Yes[edit]

Of course! All the reasons 11E and Hermine are. They regenerated, and it is hard to untangle the 46 deaths and $865 million. Basically the same storm.

No[edit]

STOP BRINGING UP 11E AND HERMINE!! They are clearly seperate, unlike Hermine and 11E where the $740 million and 102 death really are tangled. This can be clearly seperate, Not the same system, not even the renmant survived. Many people are already calling for a split, which should occur. Not the same.

Verdict[edit]

The verdict is that they should be split, LightandDark2000 was clearly an involved person who cannot learn to concede, and a merge is pointless. To spread this knowledge to Wikipedia, please click wp: Talk: Tropical Storm Amanda-Cristobal#Requested move 27 February 2021.